Forums / Public / Investing / How can you maximize returns from mutual funds if are penalized for frequent exchanges?
| Author | Message |
ChocolateDrop
578 posts |
#53059 2007-10-13 15:44 GMT |
|
There are several mutual fund options in my 401k program. Most of which penalize or suspend you for "round trip" trading. So when the market goes down several times a year, and I want to maximize my ROI and YTD, I can't put the money into a stable value fund more than 2 times in 90 days, or 4 times total per year. Pretty stupid...so how do I get the most out of my money when I am limited to this?
Though I understand that my retirement is important, I don't see how riding in a fund that tanking is logical. Why not go into stable when the market is down and go back in when it's up? Can I rely on the fund manager to do this? My goal is to get 15% return and keep it there. I want to retire comfortably, but I want my money to work harder than it is now at 9-10%. |
|
Freedom
595 posts |
#53060 2007-10-13 15:52 GMT |
|
leave them alone for one. Quit chasing the hot areas stay basic and conserative, yoru 401 is yoru future do NOT screw it up.
As for the part you cannot put money into a stable fund more than 4 times that alone something is wrong. I get weekly paycheck and it comes out and goes into my 410k every week without any penalties. It sounds to me like this a horrible 401k plan if so I would get out of it. . |
|
FireInTheSky
590 posts |
#53061 2007-10-13 15:58 GMT |
|
In a 401(k) you should not be chasing after returns and playing with your money. You should evaluate and shuffle your money around once or twice a year.
If you consistently put money in to the funds, you are buying more shares when the fund is low and less when the fund is high. Don't play with your retirement money. |
|
SpotsNDots
561 posts |
#53062 2007-10-13 16:51 GMT |
|
There is a reason that mutual funds penalize you for frequent exchanges. An exchange is a buy and sell. And frequent buying and selling of fund shares wrecks havoc on fund managers and hurts the other shareholders.
Not only are you destroying the chances of your success in saving enough for retirement you are affecting the success of others. I do not mean to criticize you personally but rather send a message to other investors with thoughts of doing what you are doing to not do this. It is really destroying your chances of a comfortable retirement. |
|
CheeseCake
556 posts |
#53063 2007-10-13 19:08 GMT |
|
A 15% return in mutual funds is COMPLETELY unrealistic, and isn't going to happen on a consistent basis EVER!
If you dislike the 401(k) restrictions (placed on you by a company that are apparently trying to protect you from yourself!) then go work somewhere else! Presumably you have all the data for what you've been TRYING to accomplish, so try this: get the historical data for all the funds that are available to you, and actually SEE if the way you think you can make more money actually works! Don't forget, you pay a FEE inside the fund every time you switch from one investment to another, the folks executing your trades are doing it to pay their rent, not to maximize your return! To get the "most out of your money", if you are a "young person" (just a wild guess), put 100% of it in the MOST volatile fund option you have: that way, your payroll deducted contributions will buy more when the price is down, and less when it's up. Assuming the trend is up (long-term), you'll make out like a bandit without playing silly-buggers. (P.S. My 401(k) is currently invested 55% in Fidelity Contrafund, 20% in Genesis Bond Fund, 15% in International, and 10% in a junk bond fund. I've had the same allocation for 3 years, and YTD I'm up 19.2%....with no transfers & without a single trade other than the "buys"!) Quit trying so hard, you are only hurting yourself! |
|
> 1 <
follow quote monthly listings tax helps stocks pure number scores book student medical henderson thecashstation hair person aruba e parts software planned classes raisers dollar 24 didn managed big commodity file solutions ra access reality out palm trade borrowmoneynow covered note chapter11 premiums estate shor performance researching writing newsletters priorities equivalent
Categories: Foot Relief Health Insurance Employment Discrimination Traditional vs. Roth IRA Valuable Skills and Traits Free Grant College Scholarships Credit Reports Employment Background Refinancing Your Mortgage Refinancing Your Home Personal Finance Guru Penny Stocks Money Saving Tips Investment Club Save Money with Energy Bills Save Money at the Gas Pump Student Grants Financing Your Education Generate Cash In An Emergency Contract Security Student Loans Make 700 Dollars in 7 Days Credit Rating Debt Persuing Wealth Financial IQ Offshore Banking Insvestments Debt Consolidation Accountancy Save Money Effortlessly Better Money Handling Mortgages Online Trading Options Trading Payday Loan Personal Loans Retirement Planning Real Estate Refinancing Renting A House Or Apartment Retirement Savings Stock Trading Time Share Investments Trading Trading Company Commodities Trading Credit Cards Currency Trading Day Trading Extra Income Forex Trading Futures Trading Gold Home Equity Investing Charity Budgeting Life Insurance Loans & Mortgages Credit Repair Financial Training Debt Consolidation 529 College Savings Plan Travel Health Insurance Student Health Insurance Insurance For Self Employed Medical Health Insurance Low Cost Health Insurance Individual Health Insurance Health Insurance Quotes Health Insurance Plans Health Insurance Companies Group Health Insurance Family Health Insurance Business Health Insurance Affortable Health Insurance Insurance Mortgage Fundraising Bankruptcy Foreclosure Credit Score Credit Repair Brokerage Banking Charity Grant Money Refinance Family Budget Accountancy Debt Relief






